14 items:
 I Am Happy in Him (E♭) | Edwin O. Excell, 1902 |
9.8.9.8.6.6.5.5.7 |
| I Can, I Will, I Do Believe (A) | Anonymous/Unknown, 1886 |
8.8.8.6 D |
| If I Could Hear My Mother Pray Again (B♭) | John W. Vaughan |
12.10.12.10 R |
| If Jesus Goes with Me (C) | Charles A. Miles, 1908 |
13.13.12.11 R |
| If the Light Has Gone Out (B♭) | Curtis J. Williams, 1917 |
9.9.9.9 D |
| I Heard My Mother Call My Name in Prayer (B♭) | Eugene M. Bartlett, 1919 |
15.11.15.11.11.11.15.11 |
| I’m Going Through (A♭) | Herbert Buffum, 1904 |
10.11.10.11 R |
| I Shall Know Him (A♭) | John R. Sweney, 1891 |
14.11.14.11 R |
| It Is Truly Wonderful (C) | Barney E. Warren, 1897 |
7.6.7.6.7.5.7.7.7.5.5 |
| It Pays to Serve Jesus (E♭) | Frank C. Huston, 1909 |
11.10.11.8 R |
| It Will Matter but Little at Last (F) | Rufus H. Cornelius, 1924 |
10.9.10.9.12.12.12.9 |
| I’ve Pitched My Tent in Beulah (D♭) | Margaret J. Harris, 1908 |
12.13.12.13.11.12.11.12 |
| I Want That Kind of Blessing (C) | Edwin S. Ufford, 1915 |
13.13.13.7.9.10.9.9 |
| I Will Sing the Wondrous Story (E♭) | Peter P. Bilhorn, 1886 |
8.7.8.7 D |