13 items:
 Watchman (2) (G) | William B. Bradbury, 1860 |
8.7.8.7 D R |
| Eventide (E♭) | William H. Monk, 1861 |
10.10.10.10 |
| Nicaea (E♭) | John B. Dykes, 1861 |
12.13.12.10 |
| Sweet Hour (D) | William B. Bradbury, 1861 |
8.8.8.8 D |
| Solid Rock (F) | William B. Bradbury, 1863 |
8.8.8.8.8.8.8 |
| Pentecost (G) | William Boyd, 1864 |
8.8.8.8 |
| Lux Benigna (A♭) | John B. Dykes, 1865 |
10.4.10.4.10.10 |
| All to Christ (E♭) | John T. Grape, 1868 |
6.6.6.6 R |
| Campmeeting (F) | Anonymous/Unknown, 1868 |
8.6.8.6 D |
| Erie (F) | Charles C. Converse, 1868 |
8.7.8.7 D |
| Safe in the Arms of Jesus (G) | William H. Doane, 1868 |
7.6.7.6 D R |
| Sweet By and By (2) (G) | Joseph P. Webster, 1868 |
9.9.9.9.6.9.6.9 |
| Hankey (A♭) | William G. Fischer, 1869 |
13.13.13.13.7.7.7.6 |